IDEA vs MTNL: Stock Comparison
Head-to-head financial and trading comparison between Vodafone Idea Limited (IDEA) and Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL) in the Cross-Sector Peers sector.
IDEA
NSE: IDEAMTNL
NSE: MTNLKey Metrics Comparison Table
| Metric | IDEA | MTNL | Edge / Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current Market Price (CMP) | ₹12.64 | ₹24.66 | — |
| 1-Year Price Return | +36.65% | -16.18% | IDEA (52.83% higher) |
| 52-Week High | ₹15.60 | ₹33.34 | — |
| 52-Week Low | ₹9.25 | ₹22.94 | — |
| 30-Day Annualized Volatility | 44.79% | 32.75% | MTNL (Steadier) |
| 30-Day Average Daily Volume | 481,252,363 | 2,226,106 | IDEA (Higher Liquidity) |
| Statutory Cost to Trade ₹1 Lakh | ₹118.50 | ₹118.50 | Identical statutory tariff |
Frequently Asked Questions
Between IDEA and MTNL, which stock gave better returns over the last year?
IDEA has outperformed MTNL over the past 12 months with a gain of 36.65% compared to -16.18%.
Which stock is less volatile: IDEA or MTNL?
MTNL demonstrated lower price volatility (32.75% annualized) compared to IDEA (44.79%). Lower volatility generally indicates steadier price action during market downturns.
What is the statutory cost to buy ₹1,00,000 of IDEA vs MTNL?
Statutory exchange and government charges (STT, NSE turnover fees, SEBI fee, Stamp duty, and GST) are identical for delivery purchases of equal rupee value across both stocks, totaling approximately ₹118.50 on discount brokers offering zero delivery brokerage (like Zerodha or Dhan).
Are IDEA and MTNL direct sector competitors?
Yes, both companies operate within the Cross-Sector Peers sector in India and are actively tracked as sector peers by institutional and retail market participants.